Image courtesy of Crosby Street Hotel, Firmdale Hotels
New York City is filled with culture-rich neighborhoods, iconic landmarks and endless experiences: Wander among towering Midtown skyscrapers, historic streets in Greenwich Village, trendy boutiques in SoHo… This dynamic city is packed with sights and activities for all interests. Below, we offer an expert-sourced New York itinerary based on a recent Fora scouting trip.
For tailored help planning your own unforgettable New York itinerary, book your trip with a Fora Advisor. They’ll guide you through the best options — whether it's exploring the art at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, catching a Broadway show or taking a stroll through Central Park (or all three and more) — and help you find accommodations that suit your style and budget.
A New York itinerary inspired by Fora’s 2024 New York FAM trip
Fora regularly runs familiarization trips (FAM trips) to boost Fora travel advisors’ expertise and familiarity with destinations around the world. In August 2024, Firmdale hosted a team of advisors in New York, where Fora is headquartered. This New York itinerary is based on their experiences and input. Our advisors were very busy during their three-day trip, so this itinerary is packed with things to do. A few advisors stayed longer to explore additional aspects of the city (we cover recommendations based on those experiences, too).
New York itinerary day 1: Arrive, get your bearings and cruise New York Harbor
After arriving in New York City, our team of Fora Advisors met at a coffee shop before hitting the town. Take time to explore your hotel’s neighborhood before venturing further afield.
Explore SoHo
Image courtesy of Soho Grand Hotel
Exploring SoHo — short for South of Houston Street — is a great way to kickstart a New York itinerary. Cast-iron accents on buildings, cobblestone streets and a lineup of high-end shops and restaurants make SoHo, as Fora Advisor Paige Menze said, a place where you feel like a local. Fora Advisor Jane Henzerling described the neighborhood as a “heaven for fashionistas and foodies.”
NYC sightseeing cruise: the Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island and the New York City skyline
A sightseeing cruise is an amazing way to start off your New York itinerary. Seeing the highlights from the water before visiting them up close offers a unique perspective. Our team enjoyed a NYC Sightseeing Sail Aboard the Adirondack, an intimate and relaxing experience on a sailing yacht. From the water, they saw the Statue of Liberty, sailed past Ellis Island and saw many of Manhattan’s most notable landmarks, including One World Trade Center and the Brooklyn Bridge.
Where to stay: Crosby Street Hotel or Soho Grand Hotel
Image courtesy of Crosby Street Hotel, Firmdale Hotels
Our advisors visited Crosby Street Hotel — one of our favorite boutique hotels in NYC’s SoHo neighborhood. Like all Firmdale Hotels, the property is a Fora Reserve partner, and a crowd favorite.
“Crosby Street Hotel in New York is where high design meets laid-back luxury, with every room bursting with personality thanks to its bold mix of colors and quirky art pieces,” Fora Advisor Samantha Dwinell said. “The vibe is effortlessly cool, especially in the private lounge, where you can kick back in style and help yourself to the honor bar’s top-notch drinks.”
“Even if you don't choose to stay, I highly recommend dropping by this trendy hotspot for afternoon tea, a cocktail in their sun-kissed courtyard or a movie in their 107-seat screening room,” Fora Advisor Gabby Rosansky said. “You might even spot a celeb or two.”
Chic design, luxe rooms and a buzzy vibe also make Soho Grand Hotel, one of the neighborhood's trendiest hotels, another excellent option. The property blends modern style with the artistic, industrial charm of the area, and hosts a vibrant social scene.
On the neighborhood itself, Gabby emphasized SoHo’s central location: TriBeCa, West Village and Little Italy are all accessible. Other popular areas like Midtown are a quick Subway ride (or long-ish walk) away.
Fora Perks at Warren Street Hotel:
$100 food / beverage credit, welcome amenity, breakfast daily, upgrade & extended check-in/out whenever possible.
Fora Perks at Soho Grand Hotel:
$50 food / beverage credit, breakfast daily, waived amenity fee, upgrade & extended check-in/out whenever possible.
New York itinerary day 2: Hudson Yards, High Line & Chelsea
Our advisors started day two with tours of Hudson Yards, the High Line and the Meatpacking District, before checking out one of New York City’s best museums and catching a Broadway show. FAM trips are deliberately packed (so much to see, so little time.) A Fora Advisor will plan a New York itinerary that works for you and your optimal pace.
Walking tour of Hudson Yards: the Edge and the Vessel
Hudson Yards is one of New York City's newest and most innovative developments, with uber-contemporary architecture, luxe shopping and fine dining. For incredible views, check out The Edge Observatory first. From the top of the tower, you can see virtually all of Manhattan, the Hudson, the East River and the bay. The Vessel, a striking beehive-like steel structure in the same area, also offers great views of the city.
Explore the High Line
The High Line, a public park, is a unique (and scenic) way to experience the city. It’s a former railway track that ran above the streets of Manhattan’s West Side. “With lush gardens, walking paths and stunning views of the city, it's a favorite spot for leisurely strolls, art installations and enjoying scenic urban landscapes,” Fora Advisor Lauren Platt said.
Start down by the Whitney Museum, and walk up to Hudson Yards. En route, stop by Hearth on the High Line for thoughtfully sourced burgers, hot dogs, frosés and other warm-weather fare.
Check out Chelsea Market and the Meatpacking District
Chelsea Market and the Meatpacking District offer an interesting blend of history, food, shopping and nightlife. The former is a foodie’s paradise housed in a factory building. It has a vast array of gourmet food stalls, restaurants and specialty shops. From artisanal coffee and freshly baked goods to international cuisine and even unique groceries (including an Italian market with very few English labels), the market is a must-visit for anyone who loves gastronomy. It's also home to a few boutiques, making it a great spot for shopping and discovering local goods. (You must grab a jar of Seed + Mill tahini at their dedicated stall. Also try their tahini soft serve topped with halva.)
The market is near the larger Meatpacking District, a neighborhood that has transformed from its industrial roots into a hub of fashion, dining and nightlife. The historic area attracts both locals and visitors looking for a trendy and lively scene.
“This area feels more up and coming,” Fora Advisor Lauren Platt said. “And being so close to the Hudson River and West Village was a huge perk for me.”
Visit the Whitney Museum of American Art
Image courtesy of Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown
The Whitney Museum of American Art is also found within the Meatpacking District. The contemporary design sticks out among the brick buildings and cobblestone streets (in a good way). Inside, expect a captivating collection of works from American artists.
Catch a Broadway show (our team saw ‘Moulin Rouge’)
After a day of exploring, the FAM team saw Moulin Rouge on Broadway to end the night. As Lauren pointed out, seeing a show is an integral part of New York culture, and even if you’re not a huge Broadway fan, it’s worth checking out.
“From Back to the Future to Moulin Rouge, there’s a show for everyone,” Fora Advisor Jon Herlihy said. “The energy is always palpable in the epicenter of theater.”
The members of the FAM team also stopped at Sardi’s, a famous Italian restaurant, after the show.Virtually everyone spotted cast members from the performance there (it’s not uncommon to spy other celebrities, too).
One more recommendation: “&Juliet is a fantastic Broadway show, especially because it shows only in NYC,” Fora Advisor Gunjan Sharma added.
Related guide: A Theater-Lover's Guide to New York City
Where to stay: The Whitby or The Hotel Chelsea
Image courtesy of The Whitby Hotel, Firmdale Hotels
Many of the best hotels in NYC are located in this section of Manhattan. The FAM team visited The Whitby, a three-Michelin Key hotel and Firmdale property.
Fora Advisor Jane Henzerling described The Whitby as a “beacon of style and easy sophistication.” She added, “the rooms are a delight, bedecked in Kit Kemp's colorful textiles and curated works of art. First-time visitors to NYC will appreciate the location, and art-lovers will be transfixed by the décor and enjoy easy access to MoMA just three blocks away.”
The Hotel Chelsea boasts a similar caliber of accommodations. Both hotels have an artistic aesthetic, but The Hotel Chelsea has a moody and elevated rocker vibe. Both properties are excellent complements to a New York itinerary, and a Fora Advisor can help you choose an option that best suits your tastes.
Fora Perks at The Whitby Hotel, Firmdale Hotels:
$100 food / beverage credit, welcome amenity, breakfast daily, upgrade & extended check-in/out whenever possible.
New York itinerary day 3: TriBeCa & Downtown
Image courtesy of Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown
The FAM team focused on TriBeCa and Downtown for the final day of their New York itinerary. Most Fora Advisors recommend spending more than three days in New York — unless you’re content to stick to one or two neighborhoods (and save the rest for another trip).
Walking tour of Lower Manhattan: the 9/11 Memorial, the Oculus and Battery Park
Lower Manhattan spans a few neighborhoods, including Downtown — where you’ll find Wall Street — and TriBeCa (Triangle Below Canal Street). The Fora FAM team started with the 9/11 Memorial Plaza before venturing to the Oculus and Battery Park.
“Visiting the 9/11 Memorial is a moving and sobering experience that elevates the humanity of a tragic event,” Fora Advisor Jane Henzerling said.
“It truly has to be experienced in person to fully understand the impact of that historic day,” Fora Advisor Jon Herlihy added.
On a happier note, The Oculus is a stunning, futuristic transportation hub and shopping center located at the World Trade Center. Eye-catching architecture, designed by Santiago Calatrava, makes it a must-see attraction, and visitors can explore a variety of shops and dining options inside. Nearby, Battery Park is a peaceful green space with waterfront views of the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island.
Explore TriBeCa
TriBeCa is an exciting base if you want to explore Lower Manhattan. As one of New York City’s most upscale and artistic neighborhoods, it’s made a name for itself with its historic vibe and thriving arts scene. TriBeCa, once a warehouse district, has transformed into a trendy area filled with luxury lofts, high-end restaurants and stylish boutiques.
“TriBeCa is the hottest zip code in the city, and known for its incredibly family-friendly streets and laid-back style,” Fora Advisor Paige Menze said. “This area is an amazing escape from the hustle and bustle, with cozy restaurants and coffee shops perfect for a relaxed day.”
“It’s a neighborhood that blends old New York charm with a modern, artsy flair, making it perfect for those who appreciate both history and style,” Fora Advisor Samantha Dwinell added how the neighborhood “blends old New York charm with a modern, artsy flair, making it perfect for those who appreciate both history and style.”
Fun fact: actor Robert DeNiro played a major role in shaping TriBeCa as it is today, and he’s also a cofounder of the TriBeCa Film Festival.
Where to stay: Warren Street Hotel or Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown
Image courtesy of Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown
Warren Street Hotel and Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown rank among the best places to stay in Lower Manhattan.
“The newest member of the Firmdale Hotels’ New York family, Warren Street Hotel has one of the best addresses in town in the heart of Tribeca,” Fora Advisor Alicia Anderson Pieri said. “The hotel is a brand-new building painted bright cerulean-blue,” Fora Advisor Alicia Anderson Pieri said of the Warren Street Hotel. “The location is ideal, and the aesthetic will make you feel lucky enough to have just moved into the most expensive zip code in NYC.”
Fora Advisor Gabby Rosansky had a recommendation for discerning travelers in particular: “If money is no object, I would opt for the north-facing one-bedroom suite with the terrace — it has a stunning, expansive view, even from inside.”
If you prefer luxe accommodations with a more traditional design, choose Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown. One of two Four Seasons New York locations, the TriBeCa property is “minimalist and classic,” Alicia pointed out. She added that the rooms are spacious, neutral in tone and offer a nice escape from the nearby attractions and shopping.
“For the big-spenders, the hotel offers a luxury day trip to the Hamptons via helicopter, with lunch, dinner and spa treatments included,” Fora Advisor Jon Herlihy noted.
Related article: 5 Luxe Hotels in Downtown NYC: From The Crosby to Arlo SoHo
Fora Perks at Warren Street Hotel:
$100 food / beverage credit, welcome amenity, breakfast daily, upgrade & extended check-in/out whenever possible.
Fora Perks at Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown:
When you book Four Seasons through Fora, you will enjoy exclusive Four Seasons Preferred Partner benefits. Your advisor will be pleased to give you more details.
Additional things to do in New York City
Three days will only scrape the surface of all the great things you can do in New York City. Here are a few more ideas to round out your New York itinerary. As always, a Fora Advisor can offer expert insights and tips to level up your getaway.
The Brooklyn Bridge, Brooklyn Flea and DUMBO
Image courtesy of Four Seasons Resort New York Downtown
Most travelers focus on Manhattan, but if you have the time, add a day to explore Brooklyn. A walk across the Brooklyn Bridge is a must-do, and once across, the charming neighborhood of DUMBO (Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass) awaits. Here, you can check out local cafés, riverside green spaces and boutiques.
DUMBO is also home to the Brooklyn Flea, which Fora Advisor Gabby Rosansky described as “one of the best spots for designer thrifting.” You’ll find an eclectic mix of vintage goods, handmade crafts and great food from local vendors.
Related guide: What to Eat, Drink and Do in Dumbo, Brooklyn
Midtown & Times Square
Most locals advise avoiding Times Square, but it is a major New York City landmark. Hundreds of thousands of people cross through the area every day.
“Yes, it’s touristy, but that’s part of the charm for me because I am a tourist!” Fora Advisor Liza Habash said. “I thrive on the energy and excitement that come with Midtown Manhattan’s iconic sights and attractions. It's also magical at Christmas!”
Times Square is worth visiting at least once — it’s still one of the top places to visit in New York — if only to check a box on your New York itinerary (unless you can’t stand crowds). Midtown at large, however, is worth keeping on your itinerary. Home to architectural mainstays like the Empire State Building and Chrysler Building, as well as renowned attractions like Rockefeller Center and Grand Central Terminal, it's filled with must-see sights. The area also offers some of the best shopping along Fifth Avenue and easy access to world-class dining, Broadway shows and museums like MoMA.
“Times Square and Midtown are all about energy and excitement,” Fora Advisor Samantha Dwinell said. “The bright lights, towering billboards and constant buzz make it the city’s beating heart.
Related articles: Hotels Near Times Square, NYC: 5 Exciting Options & Fora's New York Marriott Marquis Hotel Spotlight
Empire State Building
The Empire State Building is one of Midtown’s most iconic landmarks. Observation decks offer views of the city, and the classic Art Deco architecture harkens back to a time when the tower was the world’s tallest.
Midtown and Upper East Side museums: The Met, MoMA, The Guggenheim
A New York itinerary is incomplete without visiting at least one of the city’s world-class museums. Among the most notable: the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Museum of Modern Art and the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum.
The Metropolitan Museum of Art — The Met — is a renowned institution that journeys through 5,000 years of art, with masterpieces ranging from ancient artifacts to modern works. The Museum of Modern Art (MoMA), as noted by Fora Advisor Anna Dobrenski, is “packed with legendary works, from Van Gogh’s Starry Night to Andy Warhol’s Campbell’s Soup Cans.” (Anna also recommended visiting the Modern, a Michelin Star restaurant.) And The Guggenheim hosts a massive collection of Neoclassical and contemporary works, with a focus on the works of Van Gogh, Picasso and Manet. These are but three of dozens of reputable museums found across New York City. Check in with a Fora Advisor for more recommendations.
Grand Central Terminal
Another iconic landmark, Grand Central Terminal is a Beaux Arts architectural masterpiece. It's also home to great dining and shopping options, and of course, operates as a working train station.
Central Park
Central Park is a sprawling oasis in the heart of Manhattan, offering a peaceful urban escape. Spanning over 800 acres, the park features scenic landscapes, winding pathways, tranquil lakes and notable landmarks like Bethesda Terrace and Bow Bridge. Enjoy a wide range of activities, from biking and boating to visiting the Central Park Zoo or the park’s many gardens.
“It wouldn't be a trip to NYC without a stroll through Central Park,” Fora Advisor Lauren Platt said. “If you are a movie enthusiast like me, you will love seeing all of the spots in Central Park that are featured in movies.”
Lauren recommends stopping at Gapstow bridge for a “picture-perfect view of the Plaza Hotel.” Also check out the Mall, where many movies are filmed, and enjoy a paddle-boat ride beneath Bow Bridge.
West Village
Many Fora Advisors recommended exploring the West Village. Low-profile buildings and a dense concentration of bars, restaurants and boutiques give the area a unique vibe.
“I am so in love with this neighborhood!” Laruen said. “The brownstone buildings, classic stoops and the tree-lined streets: It’s such a vibrant and charming neighborhood that feels like an escape from the big-city vibes you get in NYC.”
The neighborhood’s café culture is strong. Lauren recommended Fellini or Do Not Feed Alligators in particular.
“Every corner of the West Village is packed with personality and surprises,” Fora Advisor Liza Habash said. “The quirky boutiques and cozy cafés feel like they’ve been plucked straight from a novel where everyone knows each other’s names.”
New York itinerary tips from the pros
Read on for a few more tips and insights to get the most out of your New York itinerary, all sourced from Fora travel advisors. Also remember that a Fora Advisor can offer tailored advice and itinerary suggestions. Simply reach out to start planning.
Explore beyond the touristy spots
Image courtesy of Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown
Every Fora Advisor we asked recommended skipping or limiting time spent in the tourist spots. Instead, explore the city’s lived-in neighborhoods.
“Touristy locations like Times Square can be overwhelming and don't really provide an authentic experience,” Fora Advisor Gabby Rosansky said. “I highly recommend spending some time with locals and visiting the outer boroughs to really get a real sense of NYC life and its cultural breadth.”
Fora Advisor Samantha Dwinell agreed: “Wander through the trendy vibes and chic dining in TriBeCa, enjoy classic Italian eats in Little Italy, indulge in amazing dumplings in Chinatown or savor a cozy meal on the Upper West Side. Each area has its own unique flavor, so get off the beaten path and taste the best the city has to offer!”
Wear comfy shoes and pack layers
Even a laid-back New York itinerary tends to involve a lot of walking. Fora Advisor Nancy McLaughlin noted that the subway can be hot in winter and buildings can get very cold in summer. She recommends wearing comfy shoes and packing layers so you’re not stuck being cold or hot.
Make use of the subway and ferry
New York City has one of the best public transportation sectors in the United States. The subway and ferry system are both economical and (mostly) efficient. Admittedly, the subway does have its quirks, but it’s usually easy to get where you need to go.
“My top tip for New York City is to embrace the subway,” Fora Advisor Liza Habash said. “It’s the fastest way to get around and offers a genuine glimpse into city life.”
If you need help navigating the maze of subway lines and stops, Fora Advisor Julie Spence recommends getting the Citymapper app. Always check the schedule before hopping on the subway, though; weekend construction tends to affect times.
The ferry is also worth checking out, even if you’re only going for the views. For a $4 ticket, you can see the skyline, Statue of Liberty and Brooklyn Bridge. Julie recommended taking the ferry back to Manhattan from DUMBO after dark: “The city lights will be sparkling in the river and it is magical.”
Stay an extra day (or at least leave some time in your New York itinerary to get “lost”)
Another universal tip from our Fora Advisors: Leave some time for spontaneity. (“That's when you stumble upon the greatest hidden joys of the City,” Fora Advisor Jane Henzerling said.) There’s so much to do in New York city; getting lost in it all is part of the fun.
Eat and shop local
Just about every popular chain in the United States makes an appearance somewhere in New York City. But most Fora Advisors recommend skipping the chains and checking out the city’s incredible foodie and boutique scenes. Just as there’s a McDonald’s and Starbucks location on every other street, you’ll find gastronomy from every corner of the world and eclectic, independent shops, each with their own character.
“Do you not overpack!” Fora Advisor Nancy McLaughlin said. “You will be carrying that suitcase around more than you realize. And bring some cash. It's great for tipping or picking up a few things at a bodega.”
For our community’s favorite places to eat and shop, see our definitive guide to New York City (at least Manhattan and Brooklyn).
Enjoy a tailored New York itinerary when you plan your trip with a Fora Advisor
New York City is packed with incredible experiences: exploring world-famous landmarks, enjoying Broadway shows, shopping in iconic neighborhoods, dining at top restaurants and more. To get the most out of your New York itinerary, book with a Fora Advisor. They’ll take care of everything, from arranging exclusive tours to securing your ideal accommodations.
New York itinerary: FAQs
Read on for answers to common New York itinerary questions.
Most advisors flew into JFK, LaGuardia or Newark; some drove or took the train
The best way to get to New York City depends on where you’re coming from. Most of our travel advisors flew into either JFK, Laguardia (LGA) or Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR). All three airports are 30 minutes to an hour (and usually more, with traffic) from most hotels in the city. However, if you’re visiting from the U.S. East Coast, you may prefer to take the train — most major cities offer direct routes — or drive. A Fora Advisor can help you decide which method makes the most sense.
How far in advance should I plan my New York itinerary?
Hotel bookings should ideally be made at least six months in advance (longer if you’re visiting during the holiday season or summer). Things that require a reservation (e.g., tours and restaurants) should be booked as soon as you’re ready. From there, you can plan other activities and allot time to wander.
When is the best time to go to New York City?
Of the Fora Advisors we polled, each recommended visiting in fall, but acknowledged there’s plenty to do and see year round.
“I absolutely love NYC in the fall!” Fora Advisor Gabby Rosansky said. “The leaves change and the air is crisp, making it a perfect time for both enjoying the outdoors and cozying up inside.”
To avoid the crowds, also consider January through March, Fora Advisor Jane Henzerling added. But bring layers.
How many days is enough to fully experience New York City?
As with any destination, the length of stay depends on what you want to do. Regardless, you’ll never see everything in one trip. You can have an amazing long weekend, and an equally amazing extended stay. We generally recommend three to six nights per visit (and there will be multiple visits).
What’s the most-visited part of New York City?
Times Square is the most-visited part of New York City, and typically attracts between 300,000 to 400,000 visitors daily. The area is especially crowded during events like New Year's Eve, when the famous ball drop takes place.
Where should I stay in NYC for my first time?
Hotels in TriBeCa, SoHo and Greenwich Village, among other neighborhoods, are the most commonly recommended. Our article on the best NYC hotels overviews over a dozen of our favorite options.
More United States travel inspiration
Check out more East Coast travel inspiration:
