Image courtesy of Montauk Yacht Club
Montauk, New York promises a quiet, breezy getaway and a mix of laid-back and upscale accommodations. Below, we breakdown five Montauk hotels — all waterfront properties recommended by Fora travel advisors.
Book your stay with a Fora Advisor and they’ll matchmake you to your ideal Montauk retreat (per your preferences and budget). Plus, they can recommend the best things to do in Montauk and the rest of the Hamptons, arrange things like ground transportation and step in to handle any travel-related issues that might arise.
What's so great about Montauk, NY?
Montauk’s natural beauty, outdoor activities and laid-back vibe appeal to a wide range of visitors. Its location at the easternmost tip of Long Island offers stunning ocean views, breezy beaches and, perhaps best of all, a sense of escape from the busier parts of the Hamptons.
5 waterfront Montauk hotels
Keep reading for an overview of five excellent hotels in Montauk, all recommended by Fora Advisors.
Montauk Yacht Club
Image courtesy of Montauk Yacht Club
Montauk Yacht Club, which recently underwent extensive renovations after it was acquired by Proper Hotels, masterfully blends Montauk’s rugged charm with the Proper’s chic, eclectic and place-specific design.
“While getting to Montauk is not for the impatient, arriving at The Montauk Yacht Club is worth the effort,” Fora Advisor Martha Pearlstone, who recently visited the property to attend a Fora x Olivia Muniak dinner, said. “It is a property that offers a bit of something for everyone.”
The property has adults-only spaces and livelier areas more conducive to families and kids. Martha also appreciated the hotel’s sense of place, made especially prominent with the views of yachts and sailboats parked in the marina.
The 107-room resort offers an array of accommodations, from waterfront rooms with private terraces to spacious cottages perfect for families or groups. Each space captures the nautical essence of Montauk — and the region at large.
“Montauk Yacht Club is one of my favorite destinations for clients looking for a perfect blend of relaxation and wellness in the Hamptons,” Fora Advisor Rabia Malik said, noting that the property’s location is convenient — it’s near a train station — “yet feels like a world away, behind lush foliage and a sweeping entryway.”
Montauk Yacht Club’s private marina is another highlight. In addition to views of yachts and sailboats, there’s a range of activities for travelers of all types. There are two pools (one for adults and the other for families), a private beach and access to a variety of watersports. The property even offers complimentary electric boat rides around the harbor.
“The perfect way to end a day at Montauk Yacht Club is a [complimentary] sunset harbor cruise with a chilled glass of rosé on their whisper-quiet electric boats,” Martha said.
Wellness is a theme at Montauk Yacht Club. There’s a state-of-the-art gym and the exclusive La Prairie Spa, where guests can indulge in luxe treatments aboard retrofitted boats docked in the marina.
For dining, the new Ocean Club restaurant, led by renowned chef Jarad McCarroll, offers a sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere, with a menu that celebrates fresh, local ingredients. (Fora Advisor Ronit Margolis, who deemed Montauk Yacht Club her new favorite resort in the area, recommended the tuna tartare and strawberry Aperol spritz.)
Best of all, as one of our Fora Reserve travel partners, if you book your stay with a Fora Advisor, you’ll unlock complimentary hotel perks.
Fora Perks at Montauk Yacht Club:
$100 hotel / resort credit, welcome amenity, breakfast daily, upgrade & extended check-in/out whenever possible.
Fora Advisor Amber Rose Powers had one last recommendation for guests staying at Montauk Yacht Club, which is overtly pet friendly: “Be sure to say hello to Teddy, the beautiful white husky mascot of the hotel who frequently makes an appearance with the resort's new stylish Managing Director, Karla Aabo.”
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Image courtesy of Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa sits on an expansive private beach. Accommodations include elegant oceanfront rooms, as well as luxurious cottages and suites — all of which take advantage of the coastal views. Gurney's also boasts high-end dining options, including the upscale Italian restaurant, Scarpetta Beach.
The big highlight, though, is the on-site Seawater Spa, home to the only ocean-fed seawater pool in North America. Unsurprisingly, the spa’s treatments harness the healing properties of the sea.
Related guide: Summer Travel Guide: Where to Stay in the Hamptons (Plus Other Essential Tips)
Marram Montauk
Image courtesy of Marram Montauk
This boutique hotel embodies the laid-back, natural beauty of Montauk's surf culture. Marram Montauk is just steps from the ocean, and has a minimalist, beach-inspired design with a focus on natural materials and neutral tones. The rooms are simple but elegant, with custom furnishings and large windows.
Marram also offers direct access to a stretch of beach; it’s a perfect spot for surfing, sunbathing or relaxing on the shore. After a day of activity (or blissful lack thereof), retreat to the on-site restaurant, Mostrador Marram, which serves locally sourced cuisine with a South American flair.
Hero Beach Club Resort
Image courtesy of Hero Beach Club Resort
For another boutique hotel in Montauk, head to Hero Beach Club Resort. You’ll love the hotel’s upbeat vibe that celebrates Montauk’s bohemian surf culture. You’ll get easy access to Montauk’s coastline, along with beautifully landscaped gardens and outdoor spaces.
The rooms at Hero Beach Club are thoughtfully designed, and feature a mix of contemporary décor and local artistic touches. Many have private patios or balconies that overlook either the ocean or garden. The resort's amenities include an outdoor pool, a fire pit — Ronit's favorite part of the resort — and a wellness program that includes yoga and meditation. Hero Beach Club Resort also hosts a variety of curated events, from art exhibitions to live music. You’ll likely find it hard to leave, but take advantage of the hotel’s complimentary bikes and ride into town.
Beachcomber Montauk
Beachcomber Montauk is a charming, oceanfront resort that offers a comfortable stay in one of Montauk’s most scenic locations. Perched on a hill overlooking the Atlantic, the resort has excellent views and direct access to the beach.
Accommodations range from studios to one-bedroom suites, each featuring private balconies or patios, kitchenettes and a cozy, beach-inspired design. Of all the Montauk hotels we’ve covered thus far, Beachcomber has the homiest feel. On-site amenities include a heated outdoor pool, tennis courts and a fitness center, all surrounded by manicured grounds.
Book your stay at a Montauk hotel with a Fora Advisor
Montauk is a delightfully relaxed destination ripe with opportunities to unwind. The best hotels in Montauk — whether you’re looking for a quiet, homey stay or an upscale sabbatical — capture that vibe.
Get the most out of your stay when you book your trip with a Fora Advisor. They’ll remove the hassle from the planning process and make sure you get your desired accommodations. Connect with a Fora Advisor to get started.
Montauk hotel & travel FAQs
Image courtesy of Montauk Yacht Club
Below, we answer a few common questions Fora Advisors are asked about Montauk hotels. You can always send your questions to a Fora Advisor for a tailored response.
What makes Montauk a popular destination? What are some things to do?
Outdoor enthusiasts are drawn to Montauk for its abundance of activities, including hiking in Montauk Point State Park, fishing in what is known as the "Fishing Capital of the World" and exploring sites like the Montauk Point Lighthouse. The town also has a vibrant food scene, with seafood shacks, farm-to-table restaurants and a variety of local breweries. Plus, Montauk's beaches, such as Ditch Plains and Kirk Park Beach, are famous for surfing, sunbathing and a relaxed atmosphere.
Related guide: 10 Things to Do in Montauk, NY
Is Montauk part of the Hamptons? Why might someone prefer to visit Montauk over the Hamptons?
Yes. And Montauk is a must-visit for any trip to the Hamptons.
Unlike some of the more exclusive Hamptons spots, Montauk maintains a bohemian vibe, which appeals to both young travelers and families looking for a laid-back beach getaway. The combination of natural beauty, outdoor adventure and a friendly atmosphere makes Montauk a beloved destination.
Related guide: An Off-Season Guide to the Hamptons & Montauk
Is Montauk expensive to visit? How does it compare to the rest of the Hamptons?
Image courtesy of Montauk Yacht Club
Montauk can be expensive to visit, particularly during the peak summer season. Activities, dining and hotels in Montauk often come with a premium price tag. However, Montauk tends to be more laid-back and slightly less expensive than the rest of the Hamptons. While Montauk offers high-end options, the overall vibe is more casual and rustic. Of course, there are also more approachably priced choices available for those looking to avoid the full Hamptons splurge. In any case, a Fora Advisor can help you plan and book a trip within your budget, per your preferences.
More New York & New England travel inspiration
Check out more United States travel inspiration in the articles below.