Curator’s statement
Forget the crowded city! If you're looking for an authentic New York experience, ditch the skyscrapers and head east. 'Bagels, Beaches, and Backroads: The Real Long Island Lowdown' is my love letter to the place I grew up, a place most people only know as a suburban blur. But trust me, Long Island is bursting with hidden gems. From the best bagel joints that rival any in the city, to stunning, sun-drenched beaches, and winding backroads that reveal charming towns and breathtaking landscapes, this guide unlocks the true spirit of Long Island. I wanted to share the secrets I've gathered over a lifetime, proving that this slice of New York offers a perfect escape for anyone seeking a relaxed, yet vibrant vacation. Discover the real Long Island, and you'll wonder why you didn't come sooner!
The Fora Difference
Book with Matthew to access exclusive perks and experiences on your trip.
Killer perks
Free upgrades, spa credits and more—we got you
Personalized recs
Customized travel planning for your style
Insider knowledge
Expert advice from people who’ve actually been there
Where to stay on Long Island
Unlock perks by contacting Matthew to book your trip.
Things to do on Long Island

Jones Beach: Dive into the quintessential summer experience at Jones Beach! With miles of pristine shoreline, this iconic New York destination offers the perfect escape for sun-seekers and wave enthusiasts alike. During the summer months, the Atlantic Ocean delivers playful, rolling waves that are ideal for boogie-boarding, body surfing or simply splashing around. Whether you're an expert surfer or just looking to cool off, the refreshing waves at Jones Beach promise endless fun and unforgettable memories. Come feel the thrill of the ocean and soak up the sunshine at this beloved seaside gem!
Long Beach Boardwalk: The Long Beach boardwalk is a vibrant, iconic stretch offering something for everyone. Spanning over 2.2 miles, it's perfect for leisurely strolls, invigorating bike rides or simply soaking up the sun and salty air. Lined with shops, restaurants and bars, it provides a lively atmosphere, while the nearby beach invites visitors to swim, surf or relax on the sand. From stunning ocean views to bustling entertainment, the Long Beach boardwalk is a quintessential coastal experience.
Adventureland: It wasn't just an amusement park. It was the place of my childhood dreams! I have so many amazing memories there, and it truly remains one of my favorite things ever. With a fantastic selection of rides, there's something for everyone to enjoy. I could spend all day on the bumper cars, and Adventure Falls? Pure, exhilarating fun! Whether you're a kid or a kid at heart, Adventureland is guaranteed to deliver a day of smiles and thrills!"
Pump it Up: As a child, I loved going to Pump It Up in Great Neck! Being on the Autism Spectrum, my family and I always felt welcomed and accommodated. It's a fantastic place for anyone looking for a fun time in a bounce house. I highly recommend it!
Splish Splash: Dive into a day of unforgettable fun at Splish Splash, Long Island's ultimate water park! With a thrilling range of rides and attractions, there's something for everyone. From heart-pounding slides that will leave adrenaline junkies breathless to relaxing lazy rivers perfect for a leisurely float, Splish Splash caters to every age and thrill level. Little ones will love the dedicated kiddie areas, while families can bond over shared adventures on multi-person rafts. Make a splash and create lasting memories at the best water park on Long Island!
Places to eat & drink on Long Island

Passione Della Cucina: Passione Della Cucina isn't just a restaurant. It's a culinary experience. If you're searching for truly exceptional Italian food, look no further. This gem boasts some of the freshest pasta you'll ever taste, and their tomato sauce? Simply divine! My personal favorite, the spaghetti with meatballs, is an absolute masterpiece. And don't even get me started on their Caesar salad — hands down, the best I've ever had! It's clear that Passione Della Cucina prioritizes quality, and every bite reflects their genuine passion for authentic Italian cuisine. It's truly one of the best places to eat Italian food, period.
The Diner Boys: Forget everything you think you know about diners! The Diner Boys in Merrick isn't your typical greasy spoon. It's a diner with a delicious twist! Prepare to be amazed by their incredibly creative and high-quality food, all at prices that won't break the bank. Craving something unique? Dive into their legendary Chicken Vodka Grilled Cheese or sink your teeth into one of their mouthwatering hamburgers. And here's the best part: they're not just for meat-lovers! The Diner Boys goes above and beyond with vegan options that are genuinely delicious, proving they care about catering to everyone. Whether you're a carnivore or a vegan, you'll find something to love at The Diner Boys — where creativity and flavor collide!
Seasons 52: Seasons 52 in Garden City, NY, offers a truly refreshing dining experience. They are known for their commitment to seasonal ingredients and culinary creativity. The menu is constantly evolving, ensuring there's always something new and exciting to discover. Forget oversized portions. Seasons 52 focuses on perfectly portioned dishes, allowing you to savor every flavor without feeling overly full. It's the ideal spot for those seeking inventive, delicious meals in a comfortable and sophisticated atmosphere.
All American Hamburger Drive In: Step into a time capsule at All American in Massapequa. With its authentic 50's design, this iconic burger joint serves up more than just food. It's a nostalgic experience. And the best part? You can enjoy a classic American meal for under $10. It's a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of the past and a great deal.
Tuti Frutti: Tuti Fruti in Long Beach, NY, has the best-tasting frozen yogurt I've ever had! I used to be lactose intolerant as a kid, and they had flavors I loved! This frozen yogurt spot is a 10/10!!
Stella’s Pizzeria: New York is synonymous with world-class pizza, and while the competition is fierce, Stella's Pizzeria in Bellmore stands out as truly top-notch. As a self-proclaimed 'frequent flyer' at Stella's, I can attest that their pizza is exceptional. I could spend hours extolling the virtues of their perfectly crafted pies, from the crispy crust to the flavorful sauce and fresh toppings. But words can only do so much — you simply have to experience Stella's for yourself to understand why it's a cut above the rest!
Mogu Modern Chinese: Craving Chinese? Prepare to be amazed! Mogu Modern Chinese is revolutionizing the Long Island food scene with a truly unique twist: everything is air-fried! Experience your favorite Chinese dishes with a lighter, healthier and unbelievably crispy texture you won't find anywhere else. Forget greasy takeout — Mogu delivers exceptional flavor and incredible service in a modern, vibrant atmosphere. Indulge in their signature Steak Hi Mein, a must-try masterpiece that will redefine your expectations. And here's the real testament: I used to work with individuals with special needs in a residential setting, and even the pickiest eaters couldn't get enough of Mogu! They were constantly requesting it! This concept is truly brilliant. If you're a true Chinese food aficionado, Mogu is an absolute must-visit. Discover the future of Chinese cuisine — fresh, crispy and utterly delicious!
Town Bagel: New York boasts a legendary bagel scene, but if you want to experience truly exceptional bagels, head straight to Town Bagel in Bellmore! They redefine what a perfect bagel should be. When anyone visits Long Island, I wholeheartedly recommend a stop at Town Bagel. Trust me, one bite and you'll be craving more!
South Bellmore Deli: South Bellmore Deli isn't just your average deli — it's a neighborhood gem! Their food is consistently delicious, but what truly sets them apart is their exceptional customer service. You'll always be greeted with a smile, especially when ordering their legendary egg sandwiches! Need to save time? Text your order ahead to 917-809-7470, and it'll be ready when you arrive. And don't even get me started on their desserts! Their pudding is absolutely divine — a sweet treat you won't want to miss. For great food and even better service, South Bellmore Deli is the place to be!
Need to know
To truly experience the beauty and diversity of Long Island, a rental car is essential. Drop the rigid schedules and explore at your own pace! I highly recommend Avis in Huntington, NY. Their friendly staff and excellent selection of vehicles make for a seamless rental experience. For ultimate comfort and space, consider their Chevrolet Suburban, or for an eco-friendly option, try their Kia Niro EV (when available). Get ready to discover Long Island on your own terms!
For more inspiration and customized recommendations, visit our New York page.

Travel Advisor
Matthew Alexander

Get in touch with Matthew
Did you like this guide? Reach out to customize and book your own experience. Or, just to chat about travel in general.
You can normally expect a response from Matthew within a business day or so. You’ll also be subscribed to our travel newsletter (you can unsubscribe at any time).