Exploring Edinburgh: Old Town vs. New Town - Choosing Your Perfect Stay & Where is the Best Area to Stay?

Icon Share

SHARE

Advisor - Abby Rieb
Curated By

Abby Rieb

  • Adventure Travel

  • Couples Travel

  • Solo Travel

  • Food & Wine

  • Arts & Culture

  • Edinburgh

  • Downtown

  • Outdoors

  • Shopping

Advisor posing in the garden with bird during a falconry lesson
Curator’s statement

I love Edinburgh for its timeless allure, where every cobblestone street whispers tales of centuries past and every majestic castle stands as a testament to its storied history. The city's vibrant energy and warm hospitality make you feel at home from the moment you arrive, while its rich cultural heritage and breathtaking landscapes captivate your heart at every turn. Whether wandering through the narrow closes of Old Town or soaking in the panoramic views from Arthur's Seat, Edinburgh holds a special place in my soul as a city of endless wonder and inspiration.

The Fora Difference

Book with Abby to access exclusive perks and experiences on your trip.

[object Object]
Killer perks

Free upgrades, spa credits and more—we got you

[object Object]
Personalized recs

Customized travel planning for your style

[object Object]
Insider knowledge

Expert advice from people who’ve actually been there

Where to stay in Edinburgh

Unlock perks by contacting Abby to book your trip.

Things to do in Edinburgh

hotel window view downtown Edinburgh

Embarking on a journey to Edinburgh is like stepping into a storybook, with each neighborhood offering its own chapter of history and charm. In this guide, we delve into the contrasting worlds of Old Town and New Town, two distinct districts that define the city's character. From the medieval enchantment of Old Town's winding streets to the refined elegance of New Town's Georgian avenues, discover the perfect setting for your Edinburgh adventure.

Old Town

Character and History: Old Town's winding streets and ancient buildings whisper tales of centuries past, drawing visitors into a world of medieval enchantment. From the imposing silhouette of Edinburgh Castle perched atop Castle Rock to the atmospheric closes and wynds that wind their way through the neighborhood, every corner is steeped in history and legend.

Rich Cultural Heritage: As the oldest part of the city, Old Town boasts a wealth of cultural attractions, including the iconic Royal Mile, a thoroughfare lined with historic buildings, museums and souvenir shops. Wander along its cobblestone streets to discover hidden gems like the Real Mary King's Close, a preserved underground street dating back to the 17th century.

Vibrant Atmosphere: Despite its ancient roots, Old Town pulses with vitality. Fueled by the lively buzz of street performers, bustling markets and traditional pubs. This is where locals and visitors alike gather to share stories and raise a glass in celebration of Edinburgh's rich heritage.

Quaint Accommodations: Accommodations in Old Town range from cozy bed and breakfasts tucked away in centuries-old buildings to charming boutique hotels boasting period features and panoramic views of the city skyline. Staying in Old Town offers a chance to immerse oneself fully in Edinburgh's historic charm and authenticity.

New Town

Elegance and Sophistication: Designed in the late 18th century as a response to overcrowding in the Old Town, New Town presents a striking contrast with its orderly grid of streets, grand Georgian architecture and spacious squares. Stroll along its wide avenues lined with majestic townhouses adorned with intricate facades and ornate balconies, and you'll feel transported to a bygone era of refinement and opulence.

Cultural Melting Pot: New Town is not only a haven for high-end shopping and dining but also a cultural hub, home to world-class galleries, theaters and concert halls. Lose yourself in the artistic treasures of the Scottish National Gallery or catch a performance at the Edinburgh Playhouse, the largest theater in the UK.

Green Oasis: Despite its urban setting, New Town offers plenty of green spaces where one can escape the hustle and bustle of the city. Princes Street Gardens, nestled between the Old and New Towns, provides a tranquil haven with its lush lawns, floral displays and stunning views of Edinburgh Castle.

Luxurious Accommodations: From iconic hotels steeped in history to sleek, contemporary boutiques, accommodations in New Town cater to every taste and preference. Indulge in five-star luxury at renowned establishments like The Balmoral or experience the epitome of boutique chic at stylish design hotels scattered throughout the neighborhood.

Comparison

Contrasting Ambiances: While Old Town captivates with its historic charm and labyrinthine alleyways, New Town entices with its elegant boulevards and cosmopolitan flair.

Cultural Offerings: Both neighborhoods boast an array of cultural attractions. Old Town's focus lies on its rich history and heritage, while New Town offers a more diverse selection of art galleries, theaters and entertainment venues.

Accommodation Styles: Whether you prefer the quaint charm of a historic inn or the modern amenities of a luxury hotel, both Old Town and New Town offer a range of accommodations to suit every traveler's needs and preferences.

Conclusion

In choosing between Old Town and New Town as the best area to stay in Edinburgh, travelers are presented with a delightful dilemma. Whether you're drawn to the timeless allure of Old Town's medieval streets or the refined elegance of New Town's Georgian avenues, each neighborhood offers a distinct and memorable Edinburgh experience that will leave you enchanted and eager to return.

So where would I stay? Luxurious Escapes: The Best Places to Stay in Edinburgh.

Embark on an unparalleled journey of luxury and Scottish charm as we unveil the top destinations to stay in Edinburgh, ensuring your visit is nothing short of extraordinary. From historic landmarks to modern retreats, each accommodation promises a blend of opulence, prime location and unparalleled hospitality, elevating your Edinburgh experience to new heights.

Kimpton Charlotte Square Hotel

Ideal for discerning travelers seeking a blend of historic charm and modern luxury. Kimpton Charlotte Square Hotel welcomes guests who appreciate spacious accommodations, impeccable service and a central location amid Edinburgh's cultural hub. Situated in the heart of the Georgian New Town, this exquisite establishment comprises seven interconnected Georgian townhouses, exuding timeless elegance at every turn.

Things to Do:

  • Explore the majestic Edinburgh Castle.

  • Embark on a walking tour of the enchanting Old Town.

Places to Eat:

  • Indulge in a culinary journey at BABA, the hotel's renowned restaurant, where Middle Eastern flavors meet Scottish charm in a stylish setting.

InterContinental Edinburgh The George

Perfect for those with a taste for sophistication and refinement, The George appeals to guests who crave an elegant retreat steeped in history, where culinary excellence meets unparalleled hospitality in the heart of Edinburgh's Georgian New Town.

Another gem of Edinburgh's Georgian New Town, The George.. From its chic interiors to its prime location, The George embodies the essence of luxury and sophistication, offering an unforgettable retreat in the heart of the city.

Things to Do:

  • Explore the bustling Princes Street Gardens, located just a short walk from the hotel, offering scenic views of Edinburgh Castle and ample opportunities for leisurely strolls.

Places to Eat:

  • Experience the culinary delights of Le Petit Beefbar, the hotel's chic brasserie serving up mouthwatering dishes inspired by Monte Carlo's renowned Beefbar concept.

Virgin Hotels Edinburgh

Designed for the modern traveler who values innovation and style, Virgin Hotels Edinburgh offers a dynamic urban sanctuary in the heart of the Old Town. Ideal for those who seek a vibrant atmosphere and cutting-edge amenities within easy reach of Edinburgh's top attractions. Step into a world of contemporary elegance at Virgin Hotels Edinburgh, nestled in the medieval Old Town. This hotel exudes a sense of novelty and excitement, with sleek design elements and vibrant communal spaces inviting guests to indulge in the ultimate urban escape. Despite its grandeur, the hotel maintains an intimate atmosphere, offering a centrally located haven for travelers seeking both luxury and convenience.

Things to Do:

  • Discover the rich history of Edinburgh's Old Town with a guided walking tour, starting from the hotel's doorstep and meandering through cobblestone streets lined with centuries-old architecture.

Places to Eat:

  • Treat your taste buds to a culinary adventure at one of the many dining establishments surrounding the hotel, offering a diverse range of cuisines to satisfy every palate.

The Balmoral

Catering to discerning travelers with a penchant for timeless elegance and luxury, The Balmoral beckons those who appreciate grandeur, impeccable service and the opportunity to immerse themselves in Edinburgh's rich history and heritage. An Edinburgh landmark, The Balmoral Hotel is adjacent to the Edinburgh train station. The Balmoral is the most traditional hotel option for clients in Edinburgh. The rooms are very large, with great views of the city. J.K. Rowling completed ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows’ in one of the suites, and clients can stay there! And it has a great Scotch bar.

Things to Do:

  • Take a leisurely stroll down the Royal Mile, starting from the hotel's doorstep and leading to Edinburgh Castle, where you can explore centuries of Scottish history and enjoy panoramic views of the city.

  • Indulge in the quintessential Scottish tradition of afternoon tea in the elegant surroundings of The Balmoral's Palm Court. Here you can savor a selection of delicate pastries, freshly baked scones and premium teas in a setting of unparalleled sophistication.

Places to Eat:

  • Indulge in the finest Scottish cuisine at the hotel's signature restaurant, offering a menu inspired by local ingredients and culinary traditions.

Gleneagles Townhouse

Tailored for travelers in search of a boutique retreat with a touch of exclusivity, Gleneagles Townhouse appeals to those who appreciate contemporary design, personalized service and access to a range of upscale amenities in Edinburgh's vibrant Georgian New Town. Located in an old bank in Edinburgh’s Georgian New Town, Gleneagles Townhouse is a private member club which also offers their 33 hotel rooms to the public. Opened in 2022, the interior design is fresh and colorful. Guests will have access to most of the member amenities when staying at the hotel, including a large ground-floor spa. The members club gives the hotel a more reserved feeling, but this is a great option for clients looking for a more modern, boutique but traditional hotel, still very upscale.

Things to Do:

  • Unwind and rejuvenate at the hotel's ground-floor spa, where you can indulge in a range of luxurious treatments and therapies.

Places to Eat:

  • Experience the vibrant dining scene of Edinburgh's New Town. With an array of restaurants and cafes just steps away from the hotel, offering everything from casual bites to fine dining experiences.

In Edinburgh, luxury knows no bounds, and our curated selection ensures that your stay in this enchanting city surpasses all expectations.

Day trips

Scottish Highlands

Need to know

This guide is based on my Fora UK FAM experience!

Advisor - Abby Rieb

Travel Advisor

Abby Rieb

Get in touch with Abby

Did you like this guide? Reach out to customize and book your own experience. Or, just to chat about travel in general.

You can normally expect a response from Abby within a business day or so. You’ll also be subscribed to our travel newsletter (you can unsubscribe at any time).

This guide is part of our ongoing series on travel to Edinburgh. For more travel tips, check out Fora Advisor Misha Sharp's guide, First-Timer's 3 Days in Edinburgh.